Trade secret litigation often turns on fast-moving disputes over information, competition, and control. Alto Litigation highlights notable rulings, verdicts, and enforcement actions shaping trade secret risk and litigation outcomes. Here’s what we’ve been watching this fall.
Apple Injunction Bid Against OpenAI Ends in a Court-Enforced Deal
Apple and OpenAI reached a court-enforceable agreement in place of a contested preliminary injunction after Judge Edward Davila of the Northern District of California reportedly said at an October 14 hearing that he was “highly likely” to grant Apple’s motion.
In its trade secret suit against OpenAI, io Products, and two former Apple employees, Apple alleges that former employees took confidential hardware plans to OpenAI and that OpenAI’s recruiting of Apple engineers was designed to extract more.
While the judge signaled his willingness to enter an injunction, he reportedly called Apple’s request to forensically inspect every device and repository containing Apple trade secrets a “huge ask.” Apple’s counsel responded that the company would limit any inspection to a small group of former employees.
At the hearing, OpenAI agreed not to use the trade secrets Apple claims were taken and to collect forensic images from the devices of 14 employees who may hold Apple confidential information, with the court retaining power to enforce the agreement. In a stipulation the court approved later that week, OpenAI also reportedly agreed to disclose any Apple trade secrets it finds, subject to review for privilege and confidentiality.
Apple also sought expedited discovery, which the court granted in part in two orders. On October 13, the court agreed with OpenAI “that some of the requested discovery is sufficiently broad such that the claim that Apple intends to ‘rummage through its former . . . competitor’s files’ is not entirely frivolous.” It still allowed narrower discovery, finding “that Apple needs early discovery to uncover the scope of any alleged misappropriation of Apple’s trade secrets, especially where there is a risk that the alleged trade secrets may become ‘so deeply entangled with OpenAI’s hardware products or other research and development efforts that the harm cannot be undone.’” The order requires:
Production of forensic images the defendants had already collected, materials used to interview Apple candidates for OpenAI’s consumer hardware group, and one defendant’s LINE messages with a third individual since January 1, 2026.
Early depositions of the two individual defendants, that third individual, and corporate designees of OpenAI and io Products.
The court declined to expedite discovery into OpenAI’s own research and development on metal finishes, power management, and battery functionality. An October 27 order added, on a 14-day deadline:
Records of one defendant’s use of AI tools, including ChatGPT, Claude, Codex, and OpenClaw, on personal and work devices and accounts.
Written responses identifying the devices, accounts, and messaging apps the individual defendants allegedly used to access, store, or share Apple information, and describing any deletion of that information.
Corporate testimony about work involving Apple information on batteries, power management, and metal finishing, about OpenAI’s interviews of Apple employees, and about steps OpenAI took to prevent use of Apple information.
The court denied requests aimed at OpenAI’s own devices, accounts, and internal investigations, calling two corporate testimony requests “too broad at this stage and better suited for merits discovery.”
OpenAI struck back on October 14, hours before the hearing, with a filing alleging that a former employee, who joined OpenAI from Apple and returned to Apple six months later, sent more than 100 confidential files about an unreleased device to personal accounts on his last day and later presented OpenAI’s product plans to senior Apple leaders. OpenAI asked for time to investigate and possibly bring counterclaims. Apple responded that it has found no evidence supporting the allegation and will continue working with OpenAI to investigate. Trial is set for July 19, 2027.
What this means: Plaintiffs with forensic evidence of file transfers may find the Northern District of California willing to order early, targeted discovery, and to signal injunctive relief, even where the defendant casts the case as an attack on lawful hiring.
That signal can be enough: here it produced a court-enforceable standstill without an injunction ever issuing. At the same time, the court kept a competitor’s R&D documents out of expedited discovery, allowing only targeted corporate testimony on work involving Apple information, and resisted a sweeping forensic inspection.
